The lights will be on, the cameras rolling and the crowd ready. Swansea City host Nottingham Forest in the third round of the Carabao Cup, and while the stakes aren’t season-defining, they are mood-shaping. For Alan Sheehan, it’s a chance to test his side against Premier League opposition. For Ange Postecoglou, it’s a chance to stop the bleeding.
Forest arrive bruised. A 3–0 defeat to Arsenal, a 3–0 collapse against West Ham, and a fanbase already questioning the new regime. Postecoglou has promised his ideas will take root, but the soil looks rocky. Swansea, meanwhile, are unbeaten in six and quietly building something.
🎯 In Focus
Carabao Cup · Third Round
Swansea City vs Nottingham Forest
Swansea.com Stadium · Wednesday 17 September · 8pm BST
Live on Sky Sports
Swansea step into the third round of the Carabao Cup with form on their side and a Premier League scalp in sight. After dispatching Crawley and Plymouth, Alan Sheehan’s side now face a Forest team in transition. The visitors arrive under new leadership, with Ange Postecoglou still bedding in his ideas and searching for rhythm. For Swansea, unbeaten in six and growing in confidence, this is more than a cup tie. It’s a chance to measure themselves against top-flight opposition and to make a statement under the lights.
🐾 Who Are Nottingham Forest?
Nottingham Forest were founded in 1865 and remain one of the oldest professional clubs in the world. Their identity is layered with history, defiance and a touch of eccentricity. The name Forest comes from their early days playing at the Forest Recreation Ground, once part of Sherwood Forest.
They’re known as The Reds, The Tricky Trees and, more obscurely, The Garibaldi — a nod to the Italian revolutionary whose redshirted fighters inspired the club’s colours. The City Ground sits beside the River Trent and carries a quiet intensity. It’s not the loudest venue, but when Forest stir, it resonates with pride and memory.
Their fanbase is fiercely local and deeply protective of the club’s legacy, especially the back-to-back European Cups won under Brian Clough. That legacy became a punchline during their League One years, when rival fans mockingly dubbed them FEC Nottingham Forest, a reference to their European Cup pedigree clashing with third-tier reality. Forest leaned into it, wearing the nickname like armour.
They are a club of contradictions. Historic but restless. Modest but mythic. Provincial but impossible to ignore.
🧠 Manager Profile
Ange Postecoglou arrives at Nottingham Forest with a résumé that’s decorated and divisive. The 60-year-old Australian has won titles across three continents, guided national teams to World Cups and ended Tottenham’s 17-year trophy drought with a Europa League win last season. He also oversaw Spurs’ worst-ever Premier League finish, placing 17th before being sacked weeks later.
Forest’s decision to replace Nuno Espírito Santo with Postecoglou raised eyebrows. Nuno had led the club to European qualification for the first time since 1995 but a breakdown with owner Evangelos Marinakis proved terminal. Postecoglou inherits a squad built for counter-attacking football and must now retrofit it to his possession-heavy, high-tempo style. That transition is already showing signs of friction.
Postecoglou’s philosophy is clear. Aggressive pressing, vertical build-up and relentless tempo. His Celtic sides overwhelmed opponents with intensity and his Brisbane Roar team once went 36 games unbeaten. But Forest isn’t Celtic and the Premier League isn’t the A-League. The question isn’t whether Postecoglou can coach. It’s whether Forest’s squad, culture and hierarchy will let him.
📉 Form Guide
Forest’s recent form is patchy, with flashes of promise and plenty of uncertainty. The last three results show a side still finding its rhythm. The next three fixtures will stretch their squad and test their tactical identity.
Last Three Matches
- Arsenal 3–0 Forest
Outclassed at the Emirates. Little control, few chances. - Forest 0–3 West Ham
Late collapse at home. Scoreline flattered the visitors. - Crystal Palace 1–1 Forest
Scrappy draw. Missed chances and loose structure.
Next Three Fixtures
- Swansea vs Forest (Carabao Cup)
A televised test against a confident Championship side. - Burnley vs Forest (Premier League)
Turf Moor will demand control and patience. - Real Betis vs Forest (Europa League)
A technical challenge in Seville. Depth will be key.
Forest’s record reads one draw and two defeats. Goals are scarce, cohesion is fragile and the pressure is building.
🎤 Fan Interview
Interview with Jake, 34, Nottingham Forest season ticket holder
“I’ve seen us in League One. I’ve seen us in Europe. I’ve seen us play with five centre-backs and no midfield. So yeah, I’m cautiously optimistic.”
Jake’s been going to the City Ground since he was eight. He’s not sold on Postecoglou yet, but he’s not sharpening pitchforks either.
“I didn’t want Nuno gone. I thought he earned the right to build. But this club doesn’t do patience. It does drama. So now we’ve got Ange, and I’m trying to get my head around it.”
Asked what he expects from the Swansea game, Jake doesn’t hesitate.
“Chaos. Absolute chaos. We’ll either press like lunatics and score early, or we’ll get picked off and look like a pub team. There’s no middle ground with us right now.”
He’s wary of the tactical shift but intrigued by the ambition.
“I’ve watched Ange’s Celtic team. It was fun. But this isn’t the SPL. We’ve got players who don’t suit that style. If he gets six months, I’ll be surprised. If he gets a year, we’re probably in Europe again.”
Jake’s final word?
“I’ll be there. I always am. But I’m bringing paracetamol and a hip flask. Just in case.”
🔄 Remember When…
Swansea 3–1 Nottingham Forest · Championship Play-Off Semi-Final · 16 May 2011
Before Forest were Premier League. Before Swansea were Premier League. There was this.
The Liberty was sold out, bouncing and borderline feral. Leon Britton’s opener was a thunderbolt. Stephen Dobbie added a second. Forest clawed one back through Earnshaw, but the moment that sealed it — the one etched into every Swans fan’s memory — came in stoppage time.
Darren Pratley, from inside his own half, lobbed the ball into an empty net. Lee Camp stranded. The crowd erupted. Brendan Rodgers ran half the pitch in celebration. The pitch invasion was instant. The stands shook. Swansea City were one step from the Premier League, and we all know what happened next.
Fans still call it the best atmosphere the stadium has ever seen. Not just loud, but seismic. Not just emotional, but mythic.
A win on Wednesday may not spark a pitch invasion or rewrite club history, but it would still be a statement. For Alan Sheehan, it would be proof that momentum is building and belief is growing. And for the fans, it would be another reason to dream.
👵 Nan’s View
“Well if they play like they did against Hull, I’ll be home by half-time.”
Nan’s not interested in formations or philosophies. She wants grit, noise and someone to put a proper tackle in. She’s seen enough Swansea sides to know when the midfield’s soft and the full-backs are all flicks and no fight.
“I don’t care if Forest are Premier League. They were rubbish last time I saw them. All money and no manners.”
She’s still fuming about the late equaliser on Saturday. She blames the ref, the lino and the lad behind her who kept shouting ‘press’ like he was on telly.
“I like Sheehan. Talks sense. Doesn’t flap his arms like a chicken like some of them do.”
As for Wednesday?
“I’ll be there. I’ve got my flask, my blanket and my lucky scarf. If we win, I’ll be dancing in the car park. If we lose, I’ll be writing a letter.”
🧑⚖️ Ref Watch
Referee: Bobby Madley
Assistants: Mark Russell, Matthew Smith
Fourth Official: Ollie Yates
Bobby Madley takes charge of Swansea vs Nottingham Forest in the Carabao Cup third round. The West Yorkshire official has been refereeing in the EFL since 2010 and returned to top-flight officiating in 2022 after a four-year absence from the Premier League list.
This will be his fourth Swansea fixture in the past year. He oversaw a 2–1 win over Preston in December, and home draws against Coventry and Sunderland earlier in the season.
The Sunderland game left a sour taste. Madley sent off Charlie Patino for two yellows, waved away two penalty appeals and allowed Sunderland’s time-wasting to go unchecked. He also interrupted a minute’s silence before kickoff, drawing widespread criticism from fans and local media.
Madley is known for letting play flow but has shown a sharp rise in yellow cards this season. He’s also been accused of making matches about himself rather than the football. With Sky’s cameras present, that tendency could become an unwelcome distraction for both teams.
📸 Final Frame
This isn’t just a cup tie. It’s a temperature check.
Swansea arrive unbeaten in six, with a manager who’s quietly building belief. Forest arrive under new management, still searching for rhythm and identity. The cameras are on, the stakes are real and the crowd will feel every pass.
Alan Sheehan has rotated smartly through the early rounds. His side has shown control, grit and flashes of flair. A win here wouldn’t just be progress. It would be proof. That the project is taking shape. That the noise around Forest doesn’t drown out the football.
Expect tempo. Expect tension. Expect a crowd that remembers what this fixture once meant and what it could mean again.
Prediction: Forest are narrow favourites, but Swansea’s form and home edge make this a live upset. Final score prediction: Swansea 2–2 Forest, and then the penalty lottery once again.
🧵 Closing Thoughts
This isn’t just about Forest, or Sheehan, or the Carabao Cup. It’s about where Swansea are heading and how loudly they want to say it. A win wouldn’t rewrite history, but it would sharpen the narrative. That this team is growing. That the belief is real. That the noise is worth listening to.
Whatever happens under the lights, the signs are there. The crowd is engaged. The manager is trusted. The football is starting to speak for itself. And if it ends in penalties, that’s football. But if it ends in a win, it might just feel like something more.
No replies yet
Loading new replies...
Join the full discussion at the Welcome to the Lord Bony Stand →