After we published yesterday’s piece on growing pressure around Alan Sheehan, we received a flurry of responses. Some were supportive, others furious. One stood out. Gary from Kidwelly, a long-time Swans fan, wrote in with a passionate reply that pulls no punches. He’s baffled by the idea that anyone could be calling for Sheehan’s head this early in the season, and he makes a strong case for patience, perspective and backing the rebuild.

Gary’s words are raw, emotional and at times a little scattered, but they reflect a view we’ve heard from plenty of fans offline. He’s angry, yes, but he’s also loyal. And he believes Sheehan deserves the season to prove what he’s building. We’ve published his response below as agreed.

Yesterday’s article: Swansea City Fans Lose Faith as Alan Sheehan Faces Growing Pressure Over Poor Form –


Gary writes:-

I honestly can’t believe what I’m reading. Calls for Alan Sheehan to go? Already? We’re barely into November and some people are acting like the season’s over. It’s madness. Five points off the play-offs and people are losing their heads. What exactly were they expecting, promotion sealed by Halloween?

This constant cycle of chopping and changing managers has got us nowhere. Look back over the last decade. How many times have we hit the panic button and ended up worse off? It’s like some fans have learned nothing. Sheehan inherited a squad that needed serious work. The summer was a rebuild, not a quick fix. Anyone with half a clue could see that. And now, just a few months in, people are throwing tantrums because we’re not top of the league?

The article yesterday? Don’t get me started. It read like a hit piece. No balance, no patience, just a pile-on. I travel with fans every week, I talk to people at games, and I can tell you: Twitter is not real life. The noise on there is toxic. It’s always the same few accounts stirring it up, pretending they speak for everyone. They don’t. Most fans I know still back Sheehan. They see the bigger picture.

Yes, results haven’t been perfect. But look at the performances. Look at the structure being built. There’s a plan here, something sustainable. That’s what we’ve been crying out for. And now we’ve got it, some want to tear it down before it’s even had a chance to grow. It’s short-sighted and, frankly, stupid.

We’ve no divine right to be at the top. This league is brutal. You earn your place through consistency and belief, not by sacking managers every time we drop points. Give Sheehan the season. Let him build. Let the players settle. Then judge. Not now. Not like this.

I’m angry because I care. I care about this club, about doing things the right way. And I’m tired of the knee-jerk nonsense. If you want instant success, go play Football Manager. This is real life. And in real life, progress takes time.

Editor’s Note

Gary’s response won’t speak for everyone, and that’s the point. The debate around Alan Sheehan is real, and emotions are running high. But amid the noise, it’s worth hearing from fans who still believe in the long game. Whether you agree or not, Gary’s message is clear: patience isn’t weakness, it’s belief. And belief, in football, is everything.

His responses were not alone, we received m any comments both on here and via our social channels – a selection of which are below: –

You can also view further comments via the forum thread on the article here

 

Avatar photo

By Phil Sumbler

Been watching the Swans since the very late 1970s and running this website (in all its current and previous guises) since the summer of 2001 As it stood JackArmy.net was right at the forefront of some of the activity against Tony Petty back in 2001, breaking many of the stories of the day as fans stood against the actions where the local media failed. Was involved with the Swans Supporters Trust from 2005, for the large part as Chairman before standing down in the summer of 2020.

Loading new replies...

j
johnjubal1958

Youth Team Apprentice

20 messages 7 likes

I'm not losing faith, far from it. Some of the greatest managers and coaches went through some very difficult times before finding the right formula that led to the followed up success. He's a young coach and he's finding the right blend and formula that will lead this club to succees. The problem is as I've said before that we want our football in a fast food style and if we don't get it then sack him. Want then happens is we go looking for a manager who is usual on the merry-go-round anyway to fix the problem. Guess what, you find the new guy is no better than the previous guy right? Right!

We are at the start of November and 5pts off the playoffs and you say the fans are losing faith. What is true is the fans are no longer listening to the media anymore because most of the stuff they realise is B.S. Most of the fans I interact with understand it doesn't happen over night and the media promotes and dictates what the fans want that is not actually true! You use the "fans" as Though "you are" speaking and representing all fans but that's how the media works and the fans know it. Hence, the fan media followers are dumping media input because they got wise to what they are up to. When I said media and are referring to all forms of media. The media have the right to report but honest reporting has gone down the toilet. When using headlines as though you speak on behave of all fans then you mislead them and are deluding yourself. The delusion here is "The fans are losing faith" but that is not the case. Yes a few grip and complain but that's because they are the experts and pay attention to the media. Most say they are fans, but the truth is, they are not but the just want to write a story. Often they create a division among the supporters that don't help the club at all. Managers and coaches and end up6on the merry-go-round because of a bias in the media reports! I'm all for those fans who are dumping social media and the media as a whole becausr they realise what the media do! The fans are not stupid but the media waves its magic wand and dictate what thing are or should be. The truth is, the media does more harm than good, or haven't you woken up to this global fact yet?! If you got nothing positive to say about the club as a whole then go and write about the government where there lots of negativity there you can dig out and guess what, you'll find its all true!!

Reply 6 Likes

click to expand...
j
johnjubal1958

Youth Team Apprentice

20 messages 7 likes

.... A quick PS. The fast food metaphor I used is like saying, I want to have patience, and I want it now!!! Get my point🤔?

Reply 1 Like

A
AlexanderDex

North Banker

3 messages 1 likes

Alright, alright, settle down. While I admire your unwavering optimism, painting a picture of some grand media conspiracy seems a tad dramatic, doesn't it? We're talking about football, not the Illuminati.

Sure, some managers take time to find their footing, and knee-jerk reactions are rarely the answer. But let's not pretend that patience is infinite, or that every "project" is destined for success. Five points off the playoffs in November is hardly cause for celebration; it's just clinging to mediocrity. And frankly, suggesting fans who express concern are just media puppets is pretty patronising. People are allowed to have their own opinions, you know.

Besides, dismissing all media as inherently biased and untrustworthy is a sweeping generalisation. There are plenty of reporters who strive for accuracy and fairness, even if they don't always paint a rosy picture. Maybe instead of accusing everyone of pushing an agenda, we could acknowledge that sometimes, the truth just isn't pretty.

After all, even the most skilled craftsman can’t polish a turd, no matter how long they’re given.

Reply 1 Like

click to expand...
Avatar of Smurph
Smurph

Roger Freestone

6,596 messages 4,189 likes

I'm not losing faith as such, it's still miles better than we've been used to over the last three, four seasons. I am getting slightly bored at the moment.

Reply 1 Like

Avatar of JackSomething
JackSomething

Ivor Allchurch

4,731 messages 1,325 likes

That 'article' is a pretty pathetic opinion piece at best.

Reply 2 Likes

j
johnjubal1958

Youth Team Apprentice

20 messages 7 likes

The point was the managerial merry-go-round doesn't solve the problem, it causes the problem because no one has patience anymore. Your concerns are noted and understandable, but it's evident from the general perspective you're not happy with the ways things are going right now. It's based on the Fast Food metaphor! Faith is really a long term discipline not short, sharp and wallah there you have it, It can't be microwaved! Any discipline especially when you starting off is touch and there to many in the world today who enjoy individuals fail. Me, I will have nothing to do with that! They wouldn't admit it of course but the media does nothing more than drag a person down. One good example is the News. 99% of it is bad news right (ask yourself, what does that do to the human spirit?) and at the end of the boardcast they say something like; "And Finally" Mrs Jones had 6 babies today blah blah blah! Basically, they are taking the P**s out of you, their adherers. The know (The illuminati as you say, who are not the real power player's by the way, and are just a tool used for the real puppet master's and power player's who stay well out of sight and away from public attention!) continuously hitting the masses with bad news does something unhealthy to the human spirit that manifests into the physical form of the body. It's no accidents I can assure you it was well planned using things like the 24/7 think tanks!

Fans around the world suffer from the knock on effect of the constant negativity they taking in on a daily bases. It's the same as the computing term, Garbage In, Garbage Out or GIGO. They fill the people wish garbage and the nature output is garbage but they don't see very often the good stuff input into their lives. You can give what you don't have. Meaning if the mass majority of your daily input is garbage then most of the time garbage comes out right! People want to let off steam and they will find a way to off load it. Like any pressure cooker it builds up pressure when the heat is on, if it's not let out it will explored! It has a valve on top to release the steam and built up pressure. This is what we are all see happening around us constantly and naturally the pressure is really high and the valve is being broken!

Remember, it was you who mention the illuminated. As for me, I have studied them as one does under a microscope. I know everything what makes tick and the fans; well they are just another obstacle that will be overcome. After all what the fans don't know are kept secret right, even though it's in plain sight!

I'm a fan like everyone else out there, I know what's going on in the world and why it's happening. My steam is my passion and understand why there is so much negativity in the world. I'm no different from any other fan but I just see things differently!!!

Reply Like

click to expand...
Avatar of J_B
J_B

Ivor Allchurch

4,848 messages 1,170 likes

Having spent a bit in the summer I'm sure that the owners want to see an improvement overall.
I'd be very surprised if they're of a mind to change the manager before the end of the season when they can properly assess the situation unless we're threatened with relegation.
Changing now would mean paying off Sheehan and his coaching team for the remainder of their contracts and finding a new manager who would bring in his coaching team.
That's an expensive change when there's plenty of time to see whether Sheehan can produce the improvement that would be considered acceptable. You would hope that the summer recruits will improve as the season wears on as they gel into the team we all hope to see and Sheehan finds the formation to get the best out of them.

Reply 1 Like

click to expand...
Avatar of Swanjaxs
Swanjaxs

Roger Freestone

18,004 messages 4,245 likes

Could have and should have scored a couple more in the second half yesterday. I expect Adam Idah to kick on now after the superb strike. Watch this space.

Reply 1 Like

Avatar of Smurph
Smurph

Roger Freestone

6,596 messages 4,189 likes

His time to shine and prove the doubters wrong. I'm looking forward to him getting a run of games, I like the lad.

Reply 1 Like

F
Flash

Reserve Team Player

66 messages 76 likes

God if you’re going to write a negative article at least have the decency to write it yourself and not rely on chat gpt to do it for you. I honestly lose interest as soon as I see obviously AI written stuff.

People seem quick to forget that we have been bad for 3-4 seasons. And not only bad but we were on a slow and steady decline down the table each season.

This season may not be as exciting as I’d hoped but I feel like the club have taken steps to stop that decline. And I’m optimistic there’s still potential to reverse it and climb up the table.

Reply 4 Likes

s
sit_down_jack

First Team Player

249 messages 222 likes

Agree with most of the points made in this article.

I honestly don’t get the optimism from some and I wish I could have whatever you are all drinking!

To me we are worse than we’ve been in the last 3 to 4 seasons. Only beating the bottom 4 and doing next to nothing in attack. The squad may not be instantly ready for top 6 but it’s a lot better than lower-midtable.

Reply Like