• We have today (22nd April) confirmed the closure of JackArmy.net on 31st May. Our reasons are varied but after a twenty-five year stint at the heart of the online Swansea City community, the time is right for us to bow out. You can read more at the link below https://jackarmy.net/2026/04/22/jackarmy-net-twenty-five-years-and-out/

Badfinger with George Harrison

  • Thread starter Thread starter Darran
  • Start date Start date
  • Replies Replies: Replies 6
  • Views Views: Views 1,477
Wasn't "Without You" written for George by Pete Ham but he said you do it instead?
 
dickythorpe said:
Wasn't "Without You" written for George by Pete Ham but he said you do it instead?


Both Peter Ham and Tommy Evans had written songs for their then girlfriends, and decided to merge the songs together, and came up "Without You"

After they recorded it, they decided it wasn't good enough as a single, so used it as an album filler on "No Dice"




https://youtu.be/R_b9_RnorqA


The rest is history (SAD) ...

RIP. "Piggy"
 
TheLoneRanger said:
dickythorpe said:
Wasn't "Without You" written for George by Pete Ham but he said you do it instead?


Both Peter Ham and Tommy Evans had written songs for their then girlfriends, and decided to merge the songs together, and came up "Without You"

After they recorded it, they decided it wasn't good enough as a single, so used it as an album filler on "No Dice"




https://youtu.be/R_b9_RnorqA


The rest is history (SAD) ...

RIP. "Piggy"


Pete's widow had a really cool, bittersweet story about how the song was created, and her part in inspiring a line of the lyrics.

Starts at 7:45 in this clip from the BBC documentary about them.

https://youtu.be/VUJNKhfy3bo?t=464
 

The Next 6

League Table

Back
Top