Is Luke Williams time up at Swansea City – will Baggies links be the end?

Thursday, 2 January 2025, 6:30
63
2 mins read

Luke Williams’ clear reluctance to separate himself from the West Brom managerial vacancy is quite telling at the moment and has certainly put a very large block between himself and his employers that, even if the Hawthorns job doesn’t come up, may never be repaired.

Williams has had more than one opportunity to put a line in the sand and say he is not interested but it is clear that he is flattered by the links and would more than happily talk to the Baggies if/when they come calling and right now it is difficult to believe that Swansea City would stand in his way.

There can be little doubt at the moment that Chairman Andy Coleman will be more than a little miffed at the way his football manager has responded to the questions asked about the interest from the West Midlands.  From Sunday’s just bizarre comment about contacting his agent to the one at Fratton Park that referenced how they would have lost interest had they watched the abject display of the Swans in the 4-0 defeat.   They are certainly not comments of a man happy in his role and I don’t suspect that they will have done any more for Coleman then they would have done for the majority of Swans fans.

The only question now that really needs to be thought about is whether West Brom actually do make contact with the Swans and ask to speak to Williams – maybe they already have?  It is certainly the case at the moment that speculation is that an approach may have already been made for Williams although the claims are unsubstantiated but numoerous suggestions are there could be talks before the two sides meet on Saturday.  Should that happen it will certainly make for an interesting clash at the Swansea.com Stadium!.  Whether that contact comes or not remains to be seen but I would imagine that Williams is, as a minimum, heading for talks with Coleman over events of the past few days.

Embed from Getty Images

It is hard to believe that just a week ago as the Swans brushed aside QPR at the Swansea.com Stadium any of this would happen and whilst there has been suggestions that Williams was of interest to West Brom before the departure of Carlos Corberán it is difficult to believe that is anything other than twitter speculation?   As the news broke on Sunday that Williams was “of interest” to the Baggies it has spiralled since that moment with Luke installed as the bookies favourite partly fuelled no doubt by his odd choice of answers to the local press.

So now we come to what happens if West Brom don’t show an interest?   There have already been rumours that things are not good behind the scenes although there is nothing concrete to back that up to anything other than rumours.  There have also been suggestions that Williams is making his job here untenable with his comments and you can certainly understand where that rumour is coming from.   The question here is therefore how much damage Andy Coleman believes that Luke Williams’ comments have caused.   I certainly don’t buy the argument that he had made his position untenable but he has certainly made it very difficult as a relationship would almost need to be rebuilt and everyone knows that a relationship between a Chairman and a manager is essential.

As we put to bed yesterday’s 4-0 defeat at Portsmouth our thoughts for 48 hours turn to the management speculation and we sit back and wait with interest what happens next but whatever it is everyone knows that Luke Williams has done himself no favours this week and for that he only has himself to blame.

Do you want the latest news from JackArmy.net direct to your phone? Then subscribe to our Telegram channel here
Images courtesy of Getty Images, Athena Picture Agency and Swansea City Football Club.

Loading new replies...

R
Ringwood

Tommy Hutchison

1,388 messages 359 likes

LW isn't the brightest when it comes to public facing PR.

He could have responded with " my focus is here during a busy Xmas period of games to progress the group "

That would have covered his back and diverted the reporters to some degree.

There is no doubt though he would take the Albion job if offered following in the footsteps of RM working up the leagues without any notable success at this level.

Reply 4 Likes

Avatar of Smurph
Smurph

Alan Curtis

3,917 messages 2,070 likes

A particular highlight was when he mentioned Rushworth had signed on for another year.

It is getting to a stage where I'll be disappointed if he stays.

Reply 2 Likes

Avatar of Swansea93
Swansea93

Alan Curtis

3,784 messages 301 likes

To be honest the way it’s playing out he’s burnt bridges with a lot of fans in my opinion, it’ll be tough to come back from this if he doesn’t move.

Reply Like

Avatar of Smurph
Smurph

Alan Curtis

3,917 messages 2,070 likes

Majority of the fans will have the same apathy towards him as they did Martin during his twenty odd games without a win.

Reply Like

Avatar of WentToSchoolWith
WentToSchoolWith

First Team Player

449 messages 237 likes

He reminds me of myself a bit. I get the impression he's trying a bit too hard to remain casual and 'cool', meaning the words that come out of his mouth aren't really the ones he's thinking of in his brain.

I could 100% see myself saying something like 'if WBA owners were here today, they wouldn't be touching me!' as a little joke to try and break the tension without thinking through the actual connetations of what I'm saying - full disclosure that I'm not a professional football manager (sorry!).

All that being said, would be pretty keen for WBA to take him.

Reply 1 Like

Avatar of Smurph
Smurph

Alan Curtis

3,917 messages 2,070 likes

He gets paid an awful lot of money and has been doing this job at various levels for a long time. The way he deals with the media should be a lot better than this.

Reply Like

Avatar of WentToSchoolWith
WentToSchoolWith

First Team Player

449 messages 237 likes

I don't disagree, I'm not defending him.

It's something I've noticed since day one of him being here, he stumbles on his words and says the literal wrong thing quite often.

It's tough though, as he's a bit of a character, and I find myself moaning about the sanitsation and lack of characters in football, so feel harsh critiquing him for being a bit different - appreciate that he's not exactly Brian Clough, personality wise

Reply Like

Avatar of Swansea93
Swansea93

Alan Curtis

3,784 messages 301 likes

It’s just mental, next manager please don’t fist pump or sing YJB to the fans, but then again Duff didn’t and he got pelters for saying he’d rather promotion than beating Cardiff.

Reply 1 Like

Avatar of monmouth
monmouth

Roger Freestone

8,957 messages 1,140 likes

Beat WBA and many will be demanding he gets a new improved contract to keep him!

Football fans (me included) are stupid about their club one way or another.

I’d had enough of him long before yesterday, but would have happily swallowed it if we’d kept on improving and winning, and will do if we start improving and winning again. I don’t think we will though. Not sure that’s all his fault now mind…the lazy sackless overpaid lot on the pitch have far too much form for winning a couple and then having a day off. They seem happy to do that and take their barrowloads of cash. His and Martins style of play will always be garbage though, so he’s never going to change anything.

I’d be astonished if WBA really want anything to do with him after reflecting on it. They can’t surely be that stupid.

Reply Like

click to expand...
Avatar of Smurph
Smurph

Alan Curtis

3,917 messages 2,070 likes

He's been dealing with the media for a long time. The way he acts as if he's an interim manager thrown in front of the cameras for the first time.

I'm all for characters and personalities in life. I wouldn't want my CEO waffling shit like this fella does half the time.

Reply Like

Phil Sumbler

Been watching the Swans since the very late 1970s and running the Planet Swans website (in all its current and previous guises since the summer of 2001 As it stood JackArmy.net was right at the forefront of some of the activity against Tony Petty back in 2001, breaking many of the stories of the day as fans stood against the actions where the local media failed. Was involved with the Swans Supporters Trust from 2005, for the large part as Chairman before standing down in the summer of 2020.

League Table

Next Up

Forum Latest

Threads: 21,148

Messages: 289,343

Members: 4,729

Latest member: SY-

Next Up

League Table

Last 6 Results

Latest from Blog

Swansea City: Incompetence reigns through yet another window

Yesterday morning we opened the day by sharing a few articles form previous years the day after the closure of the January window.  They were from 2022, 23 and 24 where the reports (linked at the end of this report) talked about the nature of the window just passed and…

Swans TV: Croeso Lewis O’Brien | Lewis O’Brien signs for the Swans

. . . Watch Lewis O’Brien’s first interview as a Swansea City player on Swans TV after the midfielder completed a loan move from Nottingham Forest. For more information, as well as all the latest Swansea City AFC news, log onto the club's official website at http://www.swanseacity.com Subscribe on YouTube:…

Swansea City: Andy Coleman has much to answer for right now

Swansea City Chairman Andy Coleman has often asked us to judge him by his actions and all too often when we sit back and do judge him on those actions we realise just how out of his depth he is as Chairman of a professional football club. Many people will…

Don't Miss

Swansea City: Incompetence reigns through yet another window

Yesterday morning we opened the day by sharing a few

Swans TV: Croeso Lewis O’Brien | Lewis O’Brien signs for the Swans

. . . Watch Lewis O’Brien’s first interview as a