• ***IMPORTANT*** SOME PASSWORDS NOT WORKING

    There has been some issues with user passwords. Some users may need to reset their passwords to login to the forum. Please use the password reset option when logging in. If you do experience issues and find our account is locked then please email admin@jackarmy.net Thanks

First game reaction time

bakajack

Ivor Allchurch
Joined
Jun 29, 2020
Messages
4,639
Reaction score
419
Alright so the first game is out of the way and we have had our first glimpses of what kind of football we are expected to play in the Russell Martin era. Before I talk about individual performances my first reaction to how we are looking to play, we look exciting going forward but currently don't have the stable foundation at the back in the form of footballing defenders. Once we address this we could be a really exciting team to watch this season and I certainly had more entertainment from this game than I did for the vast majority of last season.

Benda
Really had me nervous with how he would carry the ball a good 10-15 yards outside of his box, ironically the howler for the pen didn't come from one of these but from trying to dribble past a player in the 6 yard box. Was nervy for a bit after the penalty and the crowd certainly did their best to unsettle him but he came through that by the end of the game. Distribution in general was excellent and very confident coming to claim corners.

Latibeaudiere
My biggest worry in the team at the moment, he looked shot of confidence and nervous during preseason and carried every bit of that into the first game of the season. Could easily have been sent off and made a number of suicidal plays that could have been punished on another day, and thats just the ones he didn't get away with. Not sure how to fix this, but that is why Martin gets paid the big bucks.

Bennett
Caught out a few times in possession as we tried to play out from the back, the uncharitable among us would say that he isn't suited for this style and is very much a Cooperball sort of player. The same could be said of Garry Monk but he learned and even if he was never a great footballer he adapted to not be a weak link. I am confident that Bennett can do the same.

Cabango
Like all of our central defenders he got caught in possession a few times, will quickly learn when is the right time to play out from the back and what plays he can and cannot make and when sometimes being safe is the best option.

Bidwell
Subdued in the first half, got involved way more in the second when we had to chase the game. Still never quite seemed to have the intensity he did under Cooper but that could just be early season and growing confident in the system to know when he can bomb forward.

Naughton
Pretty much everything I said about Bidwell can be applied to Naughton. Not sure Naughton is suited to playing a wingback in the sort of style that Martin wants, will be better suited as one of our three centre backs when we have a suitable player to cover that wingback role.

Grimes
A system of play that suits Grimes and we could see some of what he could offer today, however there was also a sense from me of wanting to avoid getting injured he never put himself about as he usually did. That lack of grit cost us the first goal when he shit out from a tackle with a Blackburn player.

Smith
Was excellent today in a way that I rarely saw under Cooper. Hoping that the ankle injury he came off with is just a scare and nothing serious, he was a vital piece of the midfield today and we didn't look the same after he came off.

Paterson
Really promising debut from Paterson for me today, always looking to play the ball into space and get into space himself and not afraid to take a man on. Maybe slightly fortunate for his goal but he is off the mark now and hopefully as he gets to know his team mates better he can really get on the same wavelength.

Cullen
Two chances today, both on target and one of which you could argue that he could have done better with. However they were on target and both required good saves from the keeper to stop him scoring. Slicker football definitely suits Cullen better than burning his retinas watching the ball to come down from the sky.

Lowe
Worked hard and more than played his part in the goal we scored, but Lowe was ultimately a victim of his own industry and was rarely in a position to really threaten Blackburn when we did break the lines and got forward. Needs to adapt again this season to a different way of playing but I think he will get there.

Dhanda
I was surprised that Yan was the sub we made for Smith and unfortunately it threw out the balance of the team just as I feared it would. One good run aside which ended in a free kick that Grimes should never have taken (this is someone who has never scored a set piece goal for us that wasn't a penalty) he just never seemed to get into the game and letting the ball run across him to set up a 2v1 which he has to thank Benda for stopping was lunacy.

Whittaker
Not enough time on the pitch to really get a fair review, created one good chance that needed some brave defending from Blackburn to stop us equalising.
 
I thought Dhanda was actually really good when he came on today… I feel that Martin’s style of football will help Dhanda. He’s technically very good… which is what this style of play demands.
 
Good stuff, thanks.

I really like the style of play. I'm just concerned that we don't have the pace in the back to pull it off, nor the skill at goalkeeper. Hope I'm wrong, but it looks like we're in for a long season with this roster. We need a couple of significant signings, desperately.
 
When I was growing up I used to watch doctor who from behind the sofa, through my fingers and partly terrified. I almost did the same for the first half today it was that scary.
But it will get better week by week, as it did in the second half and I’m sure there’ll be some signings incoming before the end of august to beef us up.
 
Magic_Michu said:
I thought Dhanda was actually really good when he came on today… I feel that Martin’s style of football will help Dhanda. He’s technically very good… which is what this style of play demands.

He had an excellent burst through the middle and nearly made something happen. The rest of the time I thought he was pure Dhanda - on the pitch, but playing very safe and you barely notice him.

If Martin can get things working do we see more runs at the defense from him, then hopefully he can turn things around for him. But for me Paterson offers much more based on that debut. And he wasn't even fit.
 
Tummer said:
Good stuff, thanks.

I really like the style of play. I'm just concerned that we don't have the pace in the back to pull it off, nor the skill at goalkeeper. Hope I'm wrong, but it looks like we're in for a long season with this roster. We need a couple of significant signings, desperately.

You don’t need three pacey centre backs - if playing a back 3 you need a cabango/Bennett in the middle and ball playing cbs either side
 
When you list the team like that it becomes scary.
 
Well I’m already excited for our next game , can’t say I said the same for two years under
Cooper - that’s what we pay our money for
 
eteb said:
Tummer said:
Good stuff, thanks.

I really like the style of play. I'm just concerned that we don't have the pace in the back to pull it off, nor the skill at goalkeeper. Hope I'm wrong, but it looks like we're in for a long season with this roster. We need a couple of significant signings, desperately.

You don’t need three pacey centre backs - if playing a back 3 you need a cabango/Bennett in the middle and ball playing cbs either side

I expect Naughton to slip in at centre back… and we’ll sign / loan another ball Playing centre back
 
Malvernjack said:
When I was growing up I used to watch doctor who from behind the sofa, through my fingers and partly terrified. I almost did the same for the first half today it was that scary.
But it will get better week by week, as it did in the second half and I’m sure there’ll be some signings incoming before the end of august to beef us up.

Cybermen were the worst. Hopefully to sort out defence. Suggestions of Naughton at CB don’t fill me with confidence.
 

Swansea City v Leeds United

Online statistics

Members online
11
Guests online
236
Total visitors
247

Members online

Forum statistics

Threads
19,167
Messages
266,826
Members
4,701
Back
Top