• Thank you very much | Diolch yn fawr

    All at JackArmy.net would like to thank everyone who has played a part on this site over the past 25 years whether that is through writing, contributing, moderating, posting or just visting and reading.

    Without any of you the work that has gone into the site would have been pointless and we will always be proud that we built, generated and managed a community that was such a big part of the Swansea City supporting life for so long.

    It has been a pleasure to bring to you the site for so long but the time is now right to turn the lights out for the last time but we do it both with a heavy heart and a sense of pride driven by the so many messages received since we announced the closure.

    The site will remain here for a period until we archive and mothball it for the last time later this summer but all aspects are in a read only format.

    Thank you though for all the memories

    Phil Sumbler
    Owner, jackarmy.net

The ‘Vítor Matos’ Managerial Thread

  • Thread starter Thread starter Swans Jack
  • Start date Start date
  • Replies Replies: Replies 656
  • Views Views: Views 56,064
you could be correct buy do not forget thr f f p rules restrict what we can and cannot do that in itself puts restrains on tghings
Not really on about the financial side of it as such. Rumours are that Hellberg was their first choice manager after sacking Williams, and if that was the case then they should have tried to secure his services then. We also waited until 3 other clubs, all potentially with much more clout than us, had sacked their managers so we would be competing against them for candidates. You don't have to be the biggest or best club around to succeed, sometimes you just have to be the smartest, as we were years ago.
 
Last season doesn't really come in to for me, they had the biggest budget in that league and met expectations.

What do you mean by the state of us and our players? We've underachieved massively this season, the playing squad is good enough to compete at the higher end of the league.

Of the pitch we're more organised than we've been for the best part of a decade.

Take away from the fact he's had a huge budget to play with at Brum, he comes across as bit of dick.

He has managed 77 games and 60 of them were last season so disregarding them entirely makes it hard to assess any manager by that logic.

If he had taken us over when he was linked, the squad was in a worse place. I will wait to see if we have improved as much as you suggest. Off field we have changed a lot, but I am yet to be sure how organised that makes us. We are not worse off but maybe only marginally better.
 
A guy who’s had 12 games or whatever it is, in management, for a second division Portuguese side, isn’t going to have a £1m release clause, surely.
Another fan site Reporting he is on average 80k a year at his Club. He will get a lot more with us but Sheehan was on around 300k a year. Not sure where these figures come from but not 1m release. Average championship manager is on 800k.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
He has managed 77 games and 60 of them were last season so disregarding them entirely makes it hard to assess any manager by that logic.

If he had taken us over when he was linked, the squad was in a worse place. I will wait to see if we have improved as much as you suggest. Off field we have changed a lot, but I am yet to be sure how organised that makes us. We are not worse off but maybe only marginally better.
Does it though? Birmingham were by far the biggest and strongest team in that disiviosn. I'm pretty surety majority of us on here could have gained promotion from League One with that squad and resource.

Our squad is far more balanced with competition for places throughout apart from goal keeper and right back. I have a feeling if I told you water was wet you'd argue it wasn't.
 
Does it though? Birmingham were by far the biggest and strongest team in that disiviosn. I'm pretty surety majority of us on here could have gained promotion from League One with that squad and resource.

Our squad is far more balanced with competition for places throughout apart from goal keeper and right back. I have a feeling if I told you water was wet you'd argue it wasn't.

Lots of managers fail with the biggest resources and best players. It is still an achievement to take a side just relegated and turn them instantly into a juggernaut. That does not guarantee that he is a perfect coach who deserves years of grace based on that achievement, but it is not nothing. Especially when it is the only job he has done so far and the only thing he can be judged on.

I think our squad is more balanced with better competition for places, especially than how it finished last season. As for your last sentence, even when I am agreeing with you or acknowledging the credibility in your points, you seem to get aggravated. This is a place to have discussions and we are having one.
 
Lots of managers fail with the biggest resources and best players. It is still an achievement to take a side just relegated and turn them instantly into a juggernaut. That does not guarantee that he is a perfect coach who deserves years of grace based on that achievement, but it is not nothing. Especially when it is the only job he has done so far and the only thing he can be judged on.

I think our squad is more balanced with better competition for places, especially than how it finished last season. As for your last sentence, even when I am agreeing with you or acknowledging the credibility in your points, you seem to get aggravated. This is a place to have discussions and we are having one.
I'm not aggravated in the slightest and yes I'm fully aware this place is for discussion. If you were a little less condescending with some of your posts it could possibly help.
 
A guy who’s had 12 games or whatever it is, in management, for a second division Portuguese side, isn’t going to have a £1m release clause, surely.

They're a fairly big club aren't they?

Although if he's on 80k a year as someone has suggested it would be weird if the buy out was 12.5 years wages!!
 
They're a fairly big club aren't they?

Although if he's on 80k a year as someone has suggested it would be weird if the buy out was 12.5 years wages!!
Are they really though? I’ve never heard of them (granted they’ve probably not heard much of us either), 10k stadium, spent a long time in the Portuguese PL which is fairly poor.
 

Members online

No members online now.
Back
Top