• ***IMPORTANT*** SOME PASSWORDS NOT WORKING

    There has been some issues with user passwords. Some users may need to reset their passwords to login to the forum. Please use the password reset option when logging in. If you do experience issues and find our account is locked then please email admin@jackarmy.net Thanks

Cameron Burgess

To play devil's advocate about a couple:

Resigning Ayew was not a terrible signing, resigning him with no relegation clauses to deal with his Premier League level wages was the problem

Roque Mesa on paper looked like an ideal signing for an understudy and successor to Leon. If I remember correctly he was near the top of relevant metrics in La Liga outside of the top three (Barca, Real Madrid and Athletic Bilbao) for a defensive midfielder. Unfortunately he couldn't adapt to the pace and extra physicality of the Premier League, but that can happen and he won't be the first to have shone elsewhere and failed in English football.

Clucas and Baston are indefensible indeed though :LOL:
How we got money at all from Villa for Baston was daylight robbery rather than paying them to take him off us
Resigning him for more than £20m was…

Agree re relegation clause.

To be completely honest, the way we signed him (and Gomis was the same) first time round was just ruinous to us as a club. The huge signing bonuses caused us no end of trouble.

And Ayew’s salary second time was unforgiveable.
 
Clucas.

Baston,

Ayew (second time).

Roque Mesa.

All absolute abominations of signings.

Different league to not signing Joey.

Those were all poor signings, although none would have relegated us by themselves. Had we signed prime Allen he would have kept us up. Huge difference.
 
Those were all poor signings, although none would have relegated us by themselves. Had we signed prime Allen he would have kept us up. Huge difference.
Trying to lowball Liverpool for 6m when they wanted to sell him for 12m was daft
Canas and Mesa had both flopped, Leon had retired and we desperately needed a controlling midfielder
 
Trying to lowball Liverpool for 6m when they wanted to sell him for 12m was daft
Canas and Mesa had both flopped, Leon had retired and we desperately needed a controlling midfielder
Mesa showed signs of quality but just couldn’t click, everything he did seemed to go wrong, but it was almost good. Canas was miles off it.
 
Ayew was quite clearly a player too good for the Championship.

Much might be made of his wage and the lack of foresight to have a relegation clause to cut down his salary but he dragged his teammates through results and was the main reason we reached the playoffs on both occasions under Cooper and he never gave less than 100% which is more than can be said for many players who find themselves playing in a division lower than they deserve to be in

I still think if we had Ayew under Potter that we would have walked into the playoffs. Ayew on one side, James on the other, Celina through the middle and McBurnie up top would have pissed most of the division. The main thing Potter's team lacked was a winner who knew how to win and get his teammates's heads back in the game if they are gone.
 

Release of the 2025/26 Fixtures

Online statistics

Members online
61
Guests online
787
Total visitors
848

Forum statistics

Threads
23,739
Messages
321,119
Members
4,799
Back
Top