Possession football overhyped?

[MrSwerve]

Make hoofball great again.

 

[Dr. Winston]

Totally agree.

I think some people mistook the Derby game as a tactical error on Sheehan's part because with the ball we weren't good.

But he had John Eustace by the balls that day imo. He came down here thinking Swansea are a pitter patter tippy tappy side, get in their faces and we'll win. He didn't expect us to get in their faces twice as much they did us, we were ready for a scrap and then some. He got taken by surprise.

I think Sheehan deserves a lot of credit for that setup, it was cleverer than he was given credit for.

Absolutely this.

I'll also chuck in his use of Jay Fulton as an additional physical presence as a major reason why we won that day. For all the stick that JF gets from certain quarters, Sheehan has used him regularly and wisely.

 

[bytholwyn]

Totally agree.

I think some people mistook the Derby game as a tactical error on Sheehan's part because with the ball we weren't good.

But he had John Eustace by the balls that day imo. He came down here thinking Swansea are a pitter patter tippy tappy side, get in their faces and we'll win. He didn't expect us to get in their faces twice as much they did us, we were ready for a scrap and then some. He got taken by surprise.

I think Sheehan deserves a lot of credit for that setup, it was cleverer than he was given credit for.

If it was Sheehan's cunning plan to win that game based on a single meaningful effort on goal all game (total expected goals 0.23) then we've made a big mistake appointing Sheehan. As it is we just got lucky on the day. It happens. Fortunately there have been a lot of deserved victories under Sheehan, so one flukey result is neither here nor there.

 

[DockerJack]

I would say that he set us up to play a certain way to win the game.
In my opinion we would have lost that game under Martin and Williams and lost easily trying to play their way at all costs.
As you say, there have been lots of deserved victories under Sheehan, but I like the fact that he finds different ways to win games.
How many managers in our past have we bemoaned not having a plan B or C?