In fairness he made these points at the start. Woefully underprepared both in terms of game time and mentally. Root, Tongue and Bethell (and to an extent Archer until he was crocked again) come out with reputation intact. I do not believe it's a lack of talent but one of application. The likes of Head, Starc, Carey, Boland and Smith showed that. Even out-of-form players did not succumb to the brain farts of Brook, Jacks and Jamie Smith. Why spend two years nurturing Bashir for him just to get splinters in his arse. I don't think Potts or Carse are good enough. Crawley and Pope are too erratic and weak. Duckett is in poor form.
Need to stick with Tongue and Atkinson. Use Archer sparingly when conditions suit. Pick a young spinner to develop and if Bashir's batting is not up to it, then pick another. Find a reliable (even boring) opener to partner Duckett. Get brook to change his mindset......