Adam Idah

[TruckerJack]

Because you discount the stat when it doesn't suit your agenda. And bringing in Piroe makes your point even more ridiculous. If you think Idah will achieve what he did with us i hsve some magic beans for you.

A 600 minute spell is not comparable to thousands upon thousands of minutes at this level. The agenda here is yours.

 

[Smurph]

By disco

The stats show his record for us, in the same division over virtually same amount of games is worse than Baker Richardson.

You made a silly remark earlier about a player being better than another because they are more enthusiastic and rather hold your hands up and admit it was a misguided comment you've dug your heals in rather than admit it was a daft thing to say to save face.

We've all been there.

 

[Cinio Dydd Sul]

A 600 minute spell is not comparable to thousands upon thousands of minutes at this level. The agenda here is yours.

Yea so all you're proving there is he hasnt been very good over a longer period of time and isn't good enough for starting place in the championship.

No agenda here - neither him or CBR are up to it. Squad players yea but CBR didn't cost us multiple millions.

 

[Cinio Dydd Sul]

You made a silly remark earlier about a player being better than another because they are more enthusiastic and rather hold your hands up and admit it was a misguided comment you've dug your heals in rather than admit it was a daft thing to say to save face.

We've all been there.

No, you've picked up on a comment made in amongst a whole lot of other factors and chose to focus on that one alone. Which is actually important for a player lacking in natural talent like Idah. Jason Scotland he isnt.

 

[TruckerJack]

Yea so all you're proving there is he hasnt been very good over a longer period of time and isn't good enough for starting place in the championship.

No agenda here - neither him or CBR are up to it. Squad players yea but CBR didn't cost us multiple millions.

He’s been exactly as good as Vipotnik, well even better than Vipotnik in fact, over a similar amount of minutes at this level.

CBR hasn’t played a good enough sample size at this level to know, it amounts to a handful of games.

 

[Smurph]

No, you've picked up on a comment made in amongst a whole lot of other factors and chose to focus on that one alone. Which is actually important for a player lacking in natural talent like Idah. Jason Scotland he isnt.

You're clutching at straws now, mush.

You literally said Bobby Wales is better because he is more enthusiastic.

That's me done, I've lost all enthusiasm for this conversation

 

[Cinio Dydd Sul]

You're clutching at straws now, mush.

You literally said Bobby Wales is better because he is more enthusiastic.

That's me done, I've lost all enthusiasm for this conversation

Read back and you'll see i didn't say that. And i bet you'll be back. You love Idah too much.

 

[Cinio Dydd Sul]

He’s been exactly as good as Vipotnik, well even better than Vipotnik in fact, over a similar amount of minutes at this level.

CBR hasn’t played a good enough sample size at this level to know, it amounts to a handful of games.

Yea thats why it's a pointless metric. Vipotnik objectively has been streets ahead of Idah and our other strikers this season. Idah has rightfully been on the bench and shown nothing to demonstrate that he should be playing more.

 

[TruckerJack]

Yea thats why it's a pointless metric. Vipotnik objectively has been streets ahead of Idah and our other strikers this season. Idah has rightfully been on the bench and shown nothing to demonstrate that he should be playing more.

Because he’s played more minutes as he was in form when Idah arrived, we only play one up front. It has no bearing at all on the statistic.

 

[Cinio Dydd Sul]

Because he’s played more minutes as he was in form when Idah arrived, we only play one up front. It has no bearing at all on the statistic.

No, the use of the statistic in this situation is what is flawed.

 

[TruckerJack]

No, the use of the statistic in this situation is what is flawed.

It’s not flawed at all. It’s showing that him and Vipotnik are very similar and demonstrated that over a large sample size.

The fact Vipotnik has played more just means he’s been playing well, which is why PL teams are looking at him and no doubt fans will want over £10m for him.

 

[Cinio Dydd Sul]

It’s not flawed at all. It’s showing that him and Vipotnik are very similar and demonstrated that over a large sample size.

The fact Vipotnik has played more just means he’s been playing well, which is why PL teams are looking at him and no doubt fans will want over £10m for him.

Yea exactly and no one in their right mind would be expecting us to sell Idah for over 10mill anytime soon. That's why this stat is worthless.

 

[TruckerJack]

Yea exactly and no one in their right mind would be expecting us to sell Idah for over 10mill anytime soon. That's why this stat is worthless.

They will when Vipotnik goes and he is on the pitch more, just like he’s shown in the minutes he’s been on the pitch for us already and all the minutes he’s been on the pitch for Norwich and Celtic before hand.

 

[Cinio Dydd Sul]

They will when Vipotnik goes and he is on the pitch more, just like he’s shown in the minutes he’s been on the pitch for us already and all the minutes he’s been on the pitch for Norwich and Celtic before hand.

Well there's no point going round in circles on this. Idah will have to prove this when his opportunity comes, but theres little so far to demonstrate it in my opinion. 1 pen, 1 freak gift (admittedly he did follow it up) and a decent shot from outside the box. Needs to show a lot more.

I hope you're right.

 

[Swanjaxs]

Well there's no point going round in circles on this. Idah will have to prove this when his opportunity comes, but theres little so far to demonstrate it in my opinion. 1 pen, 1 freak gift (admittedly he did follow it up) and a decent shot from outside the box. Needs to show a lot more.

I hope you're right.

You've been going round in circles on this all day ffs! Go to bed mun.