That’s why I don’t favour it as the next step. Dai from up the valley will put up with two thrashings, three at most before he goes back to watching village rugby. Big sponsors won’t want to be associated with empty stadiums and the format will die very quickly.
A more level playing field needs to be created, like it most certainly was when the Liberty would be packed out for the top European games. The English clubs have since been allowed to run away with spending, and I don’t know why because the country is large enough to fill the talent pool, and we’ve now got the situation where they are going bust, but miles ahead of Welsh and Scottish club rugby. I had a look at the figures, total debt of English Premiership teams is £250m, eye watering numbers in football let alone rugby, and none of the top ten are profitable. Bridging the gap to the English game is key, but I think England teams have to step down more than Welsh regions step up. Stronger salary caps would help hugely with sustainability, whilst not necessarily impacting on international performance. I hope that the respective unions can find a common solution for all home nations.