When would that have been, after the likes of Amazon flooded the market with cheaper goods or maybe after the councils in their infinate wisdom granted permission for out of town retail outlets to spring up everywhere with free parking. All of the above sounding the death nell for city centres. We all had a choice, the majority chose the cheaper, easier option. Personally I hate shopping on line, and as has been said already, the shops that have survived dont carry the amount or variety of stock they used to. It is what it is, city centres need to evolve to suit the needs of a newer type of customer. It doesnt stop us mourning (not moaning about) what has now dispearing before our eyes.