• ***IMPORTANT*** SOME PASSWORDS NOT WORKING

    There has been some issues with user passwords. Some users may need to reset their passwords to login to the forum. Please use the password reset option when logging in. If you do experience issues and find our account is locked then please email admin@jackarmy.net Thanks

Alan Sheehan-Manager for Next Season

Alan Sheehan-Manager 2025/26

  • Yes

    Votes: 72 69.2%
  • No

    Votes: 32 30.8%

  • Total voters
    104
Would the Swedish manager bring in his own players if he was appointed which could be better than what we have now.

Would Darling or LOB leave if Sheehan doesn't get the gig

Would they go anyway?

Sheehan wouldn't necessarily be a success elsewhere
That's a lot of questions with no attempt at an answer. But one thing is certain, Sheehan knows how to get the best out of our players. And that is an actual answer.
 
Poor shout, as per.
Watching from the sidelines is clearly insufficient education for you. Proper context, is everything.

Entirely different specimens playing entirely different roles with entirely different managers.

Those that compare and contrast the two without the right context - have clearly never played the game to a (half) decent level.

Tier 2/3 footy analysis, at best. As per…..
So who did you play for?
 
I’m not sure why we still have a debate over who our new manager should be.

Sheehan is proving over his spell here that he can generate a tune out of a pretty average squad of players. If the owners add in the reinforcements that we need this summer then next year could be a good one.

Why risk going with a manager who we do not know can cut it at this level when we have someone who has proven that he can. Surely there is only one sensible solution here?
 
I note that Norwich has just sacked their 'long-term, strategic thinking young starlet Scandinavian manager' who turned out to be not up to much in the Championship.

(added that for the 'I can give you of examples of successful caretakers who then failed full-time' brigade.)

Unless something dramatic happens in the last 2 games, it would be astonishing if he didn't get the job. What more are they looking for in a Head Coach than what they've seen over the past couple of months?
 
The team are clearly responding to him, even players who are out of contract, and he doesn't talk bullsh*t or throw people under the bus, and he takes full responsibility in his pressers.. there is leaders in teams and there is a leader and a team.. two separate entities.. Sheehan leads as if he's playing himself
 
I’m not sure why we still have a debate over who our new manager should be.

Sheehan is proving over his spell here that he can generate a tune out of a pretty average squad of players. If the owners add in the reinforcements that we need this summer then next year could be a good one.

Why risk going with a manager who we do not know can cut it at this level when we have someone who has proven that he can. Surely there is only one sensible solution here?
Sheehan said when he took over the firefighter role again that he didn’t want to be the manager. There is a chance he could turn down the opportunity and I think he probably would if he thought the club were taking the piss.
 
The team are clearly responding to him, even players who are out of contract, and he doesn't talk bullsh*t or throw people under the bus, and he takes full responsibility in his pressers.. there is leaders in teams and there is a leader and a team.. two separate entities.. Sheehan leads as if he's playing himself
He very much sees himself as part of the team, rather than me and ‘my team’. I like that attitude - a lot

I’m not as convinced as others seem to be, even though my instinct is always to stick not twist. Unless there’s a demonstrably better option though (and I don’t mean another possession bullshit artist) then I don’t see the board has much option…unless he asks the earth. From a risk management viewpoint, not appointing him is a pretty high risk.
 
It's kinda bonkers that in the space of less than two months we've gone from a point where quite a lot of people were dead set against giving even a caretaker job to "The cheap option" or "Watson's mate" to one where some people are getting quite aggy about the prospect of him not getting it.

The club don't have the luxury of being as changeable as the support is. They have to get this call right and I don't envy them the decision.
 
Last edited:
Sheehan said when he took over the firefighter role again that he didn’t want to be the manager. There is a chance he could turn down the opportunity and I think he probably would if he thought the club were taking the piss.
Or he took the role knowing that he would be gone at the end of the season to a coaching role at a more glamorous club.

It's a bit like the Fabio Borini situation all over again for me 😬
 
Seems Hellberg is willing to join if the clubs can agree a deal
It indicates that it's down to the clubs and he doesn't want to force the issue.
I don't think it's as straight forward with Sheehan, I think he has options that might be better than what we can offer.......and he might want more in regards to recruitment than we can financially offer.

Just my opinion.
 
Seems Hellberg is willing to join if the clubs can agree a deal
If he comes instead of Sheehan and doesn’t hit the ground running he gonna find himself as the filling in a shit sandwich very quickly. I don’t think he’d get the patience some others have.
 
If he comes instead of Sheehan and doesn’t hit the ground running he gonna find himself as the filling in a shit sandwich very quickly. I don’t think he’d get the patience some others have.
I can't see him getting the same amount of time afforded to Martin and Williams.

Sheehan has given us all a glimpse of what this squad is capable of and playing in a style of football which I've thoroughly enjoyed.

If this fella is appointed and it's more sideways and backwards, it could get toxic quite quickly.
 
Or he took the role knowing that he would be gone at the end of the season to a coaching role at a more glamorous club.

It's a bit like the Fabio Borini situation all over again for me 😬
I think you might be right 😱😱😱😱😱😱😱😱😱. Shoot me now.

I think the decision was made (by Sheehan and the club) when he first turned down the interim to end of season idea.
 

MILLWALL v SWANSEA CITY

Online statistics

Members online
65
Guests online
874
Total visitors
939

Forum statistics

Threads
22,906
Messages
310,238
Members
4,761
Back
Top