• We have today (22nd April) confirmed the closure of JackArmy.net on 31st May. Our reasons are varied but after a twenty-five year stint at the heart of the online Swansea City community, the time is right for us to bow out. You can read more at the link below https://jackarmy.net/2026/04/22/jackarmy-net-twenty-five-years-and-out/

Swansea City compensation battle with Southampton continues as claims emerge

  • Thread starter Thread starter JA News
  • Start date Start date
  • Replies Replies: Replies 22
  • Views Views: Views 4,848
Why the fck would you consider developing their players for them suitable payment?
Because, like it or not, we will always rely on loan players and Southampton has one of the best conveyor belts for young talent. After all, we are not very good at it when you think about the number of our own under 21 & under 23 players that make the match day team.
 
Because, like it or not, we will always rely on loan players and Southampton has one of the best conveyor belts for young talent. After all, we are not very good at it when you think about the number of our own under 21 & under 23 players that make the match day team.
You can't really make an agreement like that binding though can you? Southampton could just say yes we agree we'll send you players on loan. But then if we don't agree to pay full loan fees or wages percentages etc or the games played %, Southampton would refuse and even then they could covertly tell the player to not to agree to it. Ultimately the agreement wouldn't be worth the paper it would be written on.
 
You can't really make an agreement like that binding though can you? Southampton could just say yes we agree we'll send you players on loan. But then if we don't agree to pay full loan fees or wages percentages etc or the games played %, Southampton would refuse and even then they could covertly tell the player to not to agree to it. Ultimately the agreement wouldn't be worth the paper it would be written on.
Neither did a written agreement, ie contract of employment, work either!
 
Neither did a written agreement, ie contract of employment, work either!
But the sanctions for breaking a contract such as Martin had should be enforceable, whereas this loan cooperation agreement thing you're suggesting wouldn't.
 
But the sanctions for breaking a contract such as Martin had should be enforceable, whereas this loan cooperation agreement thing you're suggesting wouldn't.
Perhaps they could loan us Manning cos he ain't getting a starting spot for them next season.
 
Back
Top