Zan Vipotnik

[Frankie Burrows Cap]

Do you think Idah would score 20+ goals next season?

I don't, would be surprised if he scored 10 if he puayrd a full season. Therefore he's not an adequate replacement (imo)

Hard to judge and obviously nobody knows for certain, but he’s scored 4 this year in the equivalent minutes of less than 8 full matches according to this site
https://www.transfermarkt.co.uk/adam-idah/leistungsdaten/spieler/434223

Vipotnik might be the only striker to get 20 league goals in the Championship this year, so 20 is a big ask, but less than 10 seems overly pessimistic too.

 

[Gors Buster]

Do you think Idah would score 20+ goals next season?

I don't, would be surprised if he scored 10 if he puayrd a full season. Therefore he's not an adequate replacement (imo)

Hopefully we don’t need to sell either.
I’m going to end up in Cefn Coed saying this but 2, pacy and aggressive wingers and the top 6 is there for the taking.
The goal today is a perfect example of what we should be aiming for - driving forward, at pace, in numbers and with intent!
That’s why the top 6 are where they are.

 

[Malaga]

Only need 8th next season

 

[monmouth]

Only need 8th next season

Highly unlikely the 8th team will be promoted.

 

[swan65split]

Hopefully we don’t need to sell either.
I’m going to end up in Cefn Coed saying this but 2, pacy and aggressive wingers and the top 6 is there for the taking.
The goal today is a perfect example of what we should be aiming for - driving forward, at pace, in numbers and with intent!
That’s why the top 6 are where they are.

I said months ago try Ronald in the centre running at them, trouble is looking at today eom run, i think Ronald would have gone down!

 

[JackSomething]

Hard to judge and obviously nobody knows for certain, but he’s scored 4 this year in the equivalent minutes of less than 8 full matches according to this site
https://www.transfermarkt.co.uk/adam-idah/leistungsdaten/spieler/434223

Vipotnik might be the only striker to get 20 league goals in the Championship this year, so 20 is a big ask, but less than 10 seems overly pessimistic too.

If Vipotnik goes and Idah steps up to first choice, there will be plenty lining up to slate him if he doesn't score at least as many as Vipi has. He was written off by some before he even played for us, based on his scoring record for Norwich and his transfer fee.

 

[Malaga]

Highly unlikely the 8th team will be promoted.

True but it's a bit of end of season excitement

 

[Pacemaker]

View this content on Instagram

View this content on Instagram

Fair play to Leicester fan great camera work and view of our goal

 

[Dr. Winston]

I said months ago try Ronald in the centre running at them, trouble is looking at today eom run, i think Ronald would have gone down!

Yeah. That little tap on Eom's ankle that he rode and carried on running would in all likelihood have sent Ronald crashing to the ground.

 

[Malaga]

 

[Menston4128]

If Vipotnik goes and Idah steps up to first choice, there will be plenty lining up to slate him if he doesn't score at least as many as Vipi has. He was written off by some before he even played for us, based on his scoring record for Norwich and his transfer fee.

Whilst I wouldn't write Idah off, the problem for me is that his scoring record other than at Celtic is not great and nothing he has shown at Swansea suggests it would be otherwise if he was first choice.

I have only really seen 1 performance from Idah this season that has made me think that there is a real player in there and that was at Sheffield United the other week when he was excellent when he came one.

Sadly that cameo has been the exception and it would need to be the norm and I don't believe he would manage that and his previous at Norwich seems to back that up (I don't think goals at Celtic translate well to the Championship).

If Vipotnik did leave, then I firmly believe the next 1st choice striker isn't currently on the books.

 

[Neath_Jack]

Whilst I wouldn't write Idah off, the problem for me is that his scoring record other than at Celtic is not great and nothing he has shown at Swansea suggests it would be otherwise if he was first choice.

I have only really seen 1 performance from Idah this season that has made me think that there is a real player in there and that was at Sheffield United the other week when he was excellent when he came one.

Sadly that cameo has been the exception and it would need to be the norm and I don't believe he would manage that and his previous at Norwich seems to back that up (I don't think goals at Celtic translate well to the Championship).

If Vipotnik did leave, then I firmly believe the next 1st choice striker isn't currently on the books.

He’s hardly had a run of games for us, to be judged on. He came to us with an excellent scoring record for Celtic, forget what went before.

Vip was being written off last year as well, now he’s the second coming.

 

[WentToSchoolWith]

Whilst I wouldn't write Idah off, the problem for me is that his scoring record other than at Celtic is not great and nothing he has shown at Swansea suggests it would be otherwise if he was first choice.

I have only really seen 1 performance from Idah this season that has made me think that there is a real player in there and that was at Sheffield United the other week when he was excellent when he came one.

Sadly that cameo has been the exception and it would need to be the norm and I don't believe he would manage that and his previous at Norwich seems to back that up (I don't think goals at Celtic translate well to the Championship).

If Vipotnik did leave, then I firmly believe the next 1st choice striker isn't currently on the books.

I don't think Idah is necessarily the Vip replacement in waiting, but it's very hard for a striker to do anything off the bench in the minutes he gets. Especially with a few of his recent performances being when we're seeing games out rather than sniffing out a goal - he's effectively coming on to hold the ball up and by us some time

 

[Treehuggerjack]

Do you think Idah would score 20+ goals next season?

I don't, would be surprised if he scored 10 if he puayrd a full season. Therefore he's not an adequate replacement (imo)

Who knows
I certainly wouldn’t have had Vipi down to score 20 goals last season.
Be nice if he could though and save us a few bob.
Problem is, is that if we sell Vipi and don’t buy anyone decent up top this forum will go into meltdown and it is possible that is justified

 

[Neath_Jack]

Who knows
I certainly wouldn’t have had Vipi down to score 20 goals last season.
Be nice if he could though and save us a few bob.
Problem is, is that if we sell Vipi and don’t buy anyone decent up top this forum will go into meltdown and it is possible that is justified

We won’t buy a striker with a proven record at this level (to replace Vip) so they’ll be onto a hiding to nothing from the start, same as what Idah is having now.