• ***IMPORTANT*** SOME PASSWORDS NOT WORKING

    There has been some issues with user passwords. Some users may need to reset their passwords to login to the forum. Please use the password reset option when logging in. If you do experience issues and find our account is locked then please email admin@jackarmy.net Thanks

Summer Transfer Window

Am I the only only one who thinks this whole McBurnie saga is quite possibly his agent letting the club know that he is keen. Whether the club is is a very different matter.

To be honest, although certainly better than we have at the moment, his age and his record over the past few years coupled with his supposed wage expectations, mean, for me, we could probably find someone who’d suit us more. One thing I think would be positive is his level of enthusiasm on the pitch. He’d drag players along with him. I just worry that he will have lost some of that energy he had given he is not in his early twenties any longer.

I suspect we will sign him IF our other targets don’t materialise and IF he’s still without a club at that point. I think it likely that we will enter the loan market for our first choice centre forward. Which makes sense in some ways if we think Wales is the longer term answer.

I always liked McBurnie though I must admit. Liked his personality on the pitch as well as his play.
I thought we had debunked the whole record over the past seasons issue. Last season is the most recent - and he had the same number of assists as Ferran Torres Modric and Pepe- and one less than Griezeman and Dani Rodriguez while playing for the worst team in the league.
I think we have our heads up our own asses when we shun a track record in a superior league where the player (statistically) keeps stellar company.
IF IF we can afford the package financially we would be brain dead not to sign him - his style of play would transfotm this squad. In his position, our cupboard is bare
 
I thought we had debunked the whole record over the past seasons issue. Last season is the most recent - and he had the same number of assists as Ferran Torres Modric and Pepe- and one less than Griezeman and Dani Rodriguez while playing for the worst team in the league.
I think we have our heads up our own asses when we shun a track record in a superior league where the player (statistically) keeps stellar company.
IF IF we can afford the package financially we would be brain dead not to sign him - his style of play would transfotm this squad. In his position, our cupboard is bare
That’s a bit of a weird comparison though?

Ferran Torres had 29 La Liga appearances last season and scored 10. McBurnie had 34 and scored 3. Griezmann had 8 goals. Dani Rodriguez only played once for Barcelona?
Modric isn’t a forward.

I don’t think McBurnie is a bad player - as I said, he’s better than we have. I’m just saying his record hasn’t been great since leaving us.

He may well join - who knows. We may be left with no better options. I just suspect he’s not at the top of our list at this point.
 
That’s a bit of a weird comparison though?

Ferran Torres had 29 La Liga appearances last season and scored 10. McBurnie had 34 and scored 3. Griezmann had 8 goals. Dani Rodriguez only played once for Barcelona?
Modric isn’t a forward.

I don’t think McBurnie is a bad player - as I said, he’s better than we have. I’m just saying his record hasn’t been great since leaving us.

He may well join - who knows. We may be left with no better options. I just suspect he’s not at the top of our list at this point.
The beauty of being a fan - we all see things differently. You point out discrepancies in the comparisons - fair enough. However, I would maintain the biggest discrepancy is in the quality of team mates.
If any of those others had been playing for Las Palmas - how would have their stats have measured up - we will never know - but you have to think they would not have found it as easy surely!
 
That’s a bit of a weird comparison though?

Ferran Torres had 29 La Liga appearances last season and scored 10. McBurnie had 34 and scored 3. Griezmann had 8 goals. Dani Rodriguez only played once for Barcelona?
Modric isn’t a forward.

I don’t think McBurnie is a bad player - as I said, he’s better than we have. I’m just saying his record hasn’t been great since leaving us.

He may well join - who knows. We may be left with no better options. I just suspect he’s not at the top of our list at this point.
He is better than what we have, but is he better than what we could get for the money he would demand? I don't think so personaly. Also, when you add in the fact that we really need to be turning over players for profit to become a sustainable club then his age becomes a majour issue.
 
He is better than what we have, but is he better than what we could get for the money he would demand? I don't think so personaly. Also, when you add in the fact that we really need to be turning over players for profit to become a sustainable club then his age becomes a majour issue.
I'm sure there are players out there who are potentially better than McBurnie but I'm also aware that the majority may be an unknown quantity either at this level or in this country, or both. If we are getting someone in, we would surely have to offload at least one of Vip, Yates or Cullen and I'm not aware that we're currently inundated with enquiries about any of them so if we're lucky and are able to offload one, we'd be stuck with the other 2 and the questions we might have to ask ourselves are:

1/ Is any 2 from Vip, Cullen & Yates plus McBurnie better than Vip, Cullen & Yates?
2/ Is any 2 from V, C & Y plus an unknown quantity on loan better than V, C & Y?
3/ Is any 2 from V, C & Y plus an unknown quantity on loan better than 2 from V, C & Y plus McBurnie?

The answer to 1/ is obviously yes but the answers to 2/ & 3/ are 'we don't know, and might not find out until it's too late' so putting financial considerations to one side, which scenario is lowest footballing risk with our first competitive match only 11 days away?
 
Nothing worse than people just aimlessly requesting signings, but thought it was interesting Alan Browne is available to leave Sunderland. He's 30, but a really good midfielder in the Championship, and would fit perfectly in the cover role we're looking for at the moment. Presumably, he'd be a negligble fee, too, seeing as they got him from Preston on a free last season
 
On a seperate note (couldnt be bothered with a new thread) wasnt there supposed to be a behind closed doors pre season game yesterday/today?
 

Middlesbrough v Swansea City

Online statistics

Members online
89
Guests online
453
Total visitors
542

Forum statistics

Threads
24,332
Messages
329,727
Members
4,822
Back
Top