• ***IMPORTANT*** SOME PASSWORDS NOT WORKING

    There has been some issues with user passwords. Some users may need to reset their passwords to login to the forum. Please use the password reset option when logging in. If you do experience issues and find our account is locked then please email admin@jackarmy.net Thanks

Williams out

No illusions there mate, just plain facts. Martin was a better coach for us than Duff. Williams is better than Duff. My post-curry farts are better than Duff.
Not according to actual statistics.. he's 1% better, in the grand scheme of things Duff is probably better because he had less games to work with
 
Williams has a 30% win rate, Duff had 29% and didn't have as many games and spent far less.. but he's like super Russ In interviews and didn't get booed in a preseason friendly
Modern day versions of the Pied Piper, some people are mesmerised by all these platitudes.
 
After ten games our record is:

3-3-4

Aka 60% of our matches so far it has either worked, or has partly worked to the extent we've not got beaten.

The margins are fine at the moment. The sample size is small. You can't definitively say it isn't working any more than I can say it definitely is.

What I can't get on board with is that all this equates to being as bad as, or only slightly better than, Duff.

At the very least, Williams has us organised as a defensive unit. That was completely non existent under Sgt Major Calamity Duff, except with him we also had the same issues up top (shot shy and goal shy). It's nonsense to conflate the two, people who think it's "the same" either have very short memories or they don't truly understand what it is they're watching.
Duff's record after 10 games last season 3-3-4. 15 goals for, 13 against, One game we didn't score. I remember you being right on his back and insisting he was garbage...and I agreed.

Williams 3-3-4. 8 goals for, 7 against, Five games we didn't score

Totally not comparable, obviously. Fair play, nothing to do with any bias at all.

Duff's next 9 were 2-3-4 then sacked.

Duff didn't cut it, Williams isn't cutting it. He needs to do much better in the next 10 games.
 
Duff's record after 10 games last season 3-3-4. 15 goals for, 13 against, One game we didn't score. I remember you being right on his back and insisting he was garbage...and I agreed.

Williams 3-3-4. 8 goals for, 7 against, Five games we didn't score

Totally not comparable, obviously. Fair play, nothing to do with any bias at all.

Duff's next 9 were 2-3-4 then sacked.

Duff didn't cut it, Williams isn't cutting it. He needs to do much better in the next 10 games.
So all that really does is back up my point that we were a disorganised shambles under Duff, with nearly double the amount of goals conceded.

The difference between now and a year ago is night and day, the eyeball test does not lie. Now Williams isn't doing amazingly, I agree. Bang average in fact. But this time last year we were talking about a coach who was down there with Cullis and Bob Bradley.

Not the same. Simple as that.
 
I get the impression that if you question the manager and his tactics it means you want him gone with certain supporters.

They seem to be blinkered when it comes to their short comings and will blindly support them no matter what.

Elsewhere on the internet there seems to be one or two who revel in the misery of us losing and have done with the majority of our managers.
The thread is titled “Williams Out”
 
The thread is titled “Williams Out”
F*cking right it is, everyone was on Duffs back, why aren't you all on Williams.. you've got to be consistent and not hypocritical.. lose tonight and he has a worse win % than Duff.. he's also blown 8 million down the tube.. I feel for Duff, talk about a poisoned chalice.. why is Williams put on this pedestal just like Russ was.. Russ also attempted to do the club over with compensation.. I'm just being fair here.. you don't treat two people differently in life, you treat them all the same.. I'll say it how it is..
 
F*cking right it is, everyone was on Duffs back, why aren't you all on Williams.. you've got to be consistent and not hypocritical.. lose tonight and he has a worse win % than Duff.. he's also blown 8 million down the tube.. I feel for Duff, talk about a poisoned chalice.. why is Williams put on this pedestal just like Russ was.. Russ also attempted to do the club over with compensation.. I'm just being fair here.. you don't treat two people differently in life, you treat them all the same.. I'll say it how it is..
Oh it's £8m now. It was £6m a few days ago. We'll be up to £10m before Millwall, no doubt.
 
F*cking right it is, everyone was on Duffs back, why aren't you all on Williams.. you've got to be consistent and not hypocritical.. lose tonight and he has a worse win % than Duff.. he's also blown 8 million down the tube.. I feel for Duff, talk about a poisoned chalice.. why is Williams put on this pedestal just like Russ was.. Russ also attempted to do the club over with compensation.. I'm just being fair here.. you don't treat two people differently in life, you treat them all the same.. I'll say it how it is..
I’ve actually enjoyed a few games this season. In fact, 2 were edge-of-the-seat stuff.
We were absolute shit under Duff and would have gone down if he’d stayed.
 
F*cking right it is, everyone was on Duffs back, why aren't you all on Williams.. you've got to be consistent and not hypocritical.. lose tonight and he has a worse win % than Duff.. he's also blown 8 million down the tube.. I feel for Duff, talk about a poisoned chalice.. why is Williams put on this pedestal just like Russ was.. Russ also attempted to do the club over with compensation.. I'm just being fair here.. you don't treat two people differently in life, you treat them all the same.. I'll say it how it is..
Williams didn’t spend it though, the player selection almost certainly wasn’t his.
 
I’ve actually enjoyed a few games this season. In fact, 2 were edge-of-the-seat stuff.
We were absolute shit under Duff and would have gone down if he’d stayed.
You didn’t enjoy absolutely creaming Millwall and Plymouth away and the edge of the seat win against Norwich when Humphries volleyed the winner and a four game winning sequence? But you’re enjoying this shit?

Talk about a blind spot.
 
You didn’t enjoy absolutely creaming Millwall and Plymouth away and the edge of the seat win against Norwich when Humphries volleyed the winner and a four game winning sequence? But you’re enjoying this shit?

Talk about a blind spot.
Plymouth away was a cracking day
 

Swansea City v Leeds United

Online statistics

Members online
23
Guests online
317
Total visitors
340

Forum statistics

Threads
19,196
Messages
266,988
Members
4,703
Back
Top